Market Structure · Tokenised Securities

Same Share, Different Tax

The token's form decides which taxes attach — the paper trail decides the rate

Julian Gretzinger · November 15, 2026 · Substack

This is not tax advice. It records a practitioner's observations from public documents and marks the questions that remain open. The forms below are analytical types, not tax classifications that apply automatically to a product. Practices vary within each type, the result depends on the terms and documentation of the particular structure, and nothing here is a statement about any issuer's compliance.

Abstract

The form of a tokenised share decides what the holder recovers if the issuer fails. It also decides how the dividend is taxed on its way to the holder. For US shares held by non-US investors the difference is large: depending on the form, the dividend can be taxed once at a treaty rate, once at the full statutory rate, or, where the token is a separate instrument, under two different rules.

This essay sets the withholding-tax treatment beside the ladder of forms this library already uses for recovery. It finds that the form sets which taxes can attach, that the documentation chain sets the rate, and that offering documents rarely say which case applies. It closes with what an investor would want to ask.

The form sets which taxes can apply. The documentation sets the rate. The wallet shows only what is left.

#tokenisation  #withholding-tax  #tokenised-equity  #market-structure

I

The Hardest Class, Again

Of the mainstream security classes, listed shares have proved among the hardest to tokenise natively. Earlier essays here gave three reasons. A share carries corporate actions with choices in them, where a plain bond carries a calendar (The Dividend Is the Hard Part). The record that constitutes ownership is fixed by national law and is seldom the token (Who Keeps the Register?). And many tokenised shares in circulation were issued by someone other than the company, without its involvement (Finding Your Way in Tokenisation).

Tax is another. The Six Transformations called it tax passage: the least costly legal route between gross and net return. For US securities the route differs sharply by asset class. Interest paid to a foreign portfolio investor on qualifying US debt is, in the ordinary case, exempt from US withholding under the portfolio-interest rules (IRC §§ 871(h), 881(c)). Dividends are not. They bear 30 per cent, or a lower rate where a treaty applies and entitlement is properly established.

A tokenised US bond therefore has almost no cross-border withholding problem, and a tokenised US share has all of it. The difference lies in the tax code and has nothing to do with the technology.

II

One Choice, Two Consequences

The Wallet Does Not Tell You ranked the forms of tokenised equity by what the holder keeps if the issuer or an intermediary fails: registered share, beneficial interest, secured claim, interest with an exit, bare claim. The ranking showed that instruments with the same ticker and the same price in a wallet are different legal objects.

The same choice of form has a second consequence that receives less attention. It shapes who is treated as owning the share for tax purposes, whether the token is itself an instrument the tax rules address, and whether the paying chain can establish who the holder is. Those three facts determine what part of a dividend arrives. Legal ownership does not settle tax ownership, so each is a separate question.

What follows is the same ladder with a tax column. It deals with US withholding only. The holder's own taxation at home is a separate matter and varies by country.

III

The Rule in Brief

Two different US withholding rules can attach to the dividend behind a token.

The first is the ordinary withholding tax on the dividend itself. It is collected by the paying agent or broker from whoever holds the share: 30 per cent, or the holder's treaty rate if documented.

The second arises under section 871(m) of the Internal Revenue Code. Payments on certain securities loans, swaps and equity-linked instruments are treated as dividend equivalents and taxed as US dividends, wherever the issuer is located (IRC § 871(m); Treas. Reg. § 1.871-15). An equity-linked instrument is any other financial transaction that references the value of a US share, so a note or a contract can qualify (§ 1.871-15(a)(4)). Since 2017 the rule has applied to instruments that track the share one for one; other instruments issued through 2028 remain outside it, unless an anti-abuse rule brings them in (Notice 2026-61, Part III; § 1.871-15(o)). A dividend that is only implicit in the price still counts, so reinvestment does not take an instrument out of scope (§ 1.871-15(i)(2)(ii)). A distribution that would not be subject to US tax if the holder owned the share directly, such as a return of capital, creates no dividend equivalent (§ 1.871-15(c)(2)). The instrument's terms and issue date decide, not its resemblance to a share.

The test for when the second rule can apply is already in this library's vocabulary. A wrapper is a second instrument from a second issuer; a custodial token only adds a tier to the chain of the same instrument. A second instrument can raise a second tax question. A longer chain cannot; it needs the holder's documentation carried along it.

The arithmetic, per 100 of gross dividend:

Whether the fourth case exists in practice is the open question, and the answer turns on the party in the middle. A qualified derivatives dealer, a qualified intermediary that meets further requirements, is not taxed through 2028 on dividends and dividend equivalents received in its dealer capacity, and must withhold on the dividend equivalents it pays to foreign holders (Notice 2026-61, Part V). For a dealer the guidance therefore points to one tax. The Swiss Bankers Association put the converse to the Treasury in 2017: without that treatment, structured-product issuers would face two levels of withholding, one on the hedge and one on the client's instrument (SBA, letter of 14 November 2017). Whether a given tokenisation vehicle holds the status, or stands behind an entity that does, is a fact about that vehicle. Where the holder is treated as owning the share, there is no second instrument and the question does not arise.

A holder who receives 70 cannot tell from the number alone whether the dividend was taxed once or twice.
IV

The Ladder With a Tax Column

Two side cases belong here. A token on an exchange-traded fund that tracks a qualified index is treated as referencing the index, which is outside the second rule (§ 1.871-15(l)(2), (l)(7)). Among other conditions, the index must have at least 25 components, no single US component above 15 per cent, no five above 40 per cent together, and a dividend yield no more than one and a half times that of the S&P 500 (§ 1.871-15(l)(3)), limits that concentrated sector funds and high-dividend funds can fail. The tax on the fund's own distributions is unaffected. A token on a fund domiciled outside the United States moves the US tax inside the fund, at the rate the fund's own treaty position allows; the token's own treatment remains a question of its terms.

The pattern across the rungs is consistent. The legal form decides which taxes can attach. The documentation available to the paying chain decides the rate. A high rung does not deliver a treaty rate by itself: a registered share held through an undocumented address is taxed at the statutory rate, exactly like the lowest rung.

V

Where Treaty Relief Survives

A treaty rate is a claim made by an identified person. The withholding chain must be able to establish who the beneficial owner is, where that owner is resident, and that the treaty's conditions are met. The US payer need not see every holder: qualified intermediaries hold the documentation and report by withholding-rate pool (Treas. Reg. § 1.1441-1(e)(5); IRS, Payments to Qualified Intermediaries). What the chain cannot do without is a valid certificate for each holder and a way to allocate each payment to the right pool. Paying a dividend is the easy part; proving who may receive it at a lower rate is the hard one.

Unrestricted transfer and treaty relief therefore pull against each other. A token that can pass to wallets the paying chain has not documented gives up the lower rate, because nobody in the chain can certify the holder at the moment of payment. A token restricted to identified holders, or held through a custodian that documents them, can keep it. Transferability is not what disqualifies; the inability to establish who is entitled does.

The market has been here before. When the dividend-equivalent rules took effect in 2017, European banks issuing certificates on US shares faced the same problem: the issuer does not know who holds a certificate in a central depository. A common answer in the German and Swiss certificate markets, known as the issuer solution, was to withhold a flat 30 per cent at issuer level for every holder, with the issuing banks relying on dealer status for the hedge and on data flags to tell custodians downstream that the tax had been dealt with (SBA, letter of 14 November 2017; SIX, Section 871(m) data service). Treaty rates were not applied at issuer level because of operational limits. Token forms that show a flat deduction have arrived at the same visible outcome. On what basis is seldom stated.

VI

What the Documents Say

Offering documents for tokenised shares describe the recovery position in detail. On tax they are thinner. Reading across the types, three items are frequently missing or sit outside the approved document.

The first is the rate. Some documents state that reinvestment is net of 30 per cent. Others say only that it is net of applicable withholding taxes, and the figure appears in a distributor's help pages. What the holder sees also depends on the payout method: a stablecoin payment arrives as a visible credit, while a reinvested dividend only moves a multiplier or a balance and does not appear as an event at all.

The second is the basis. Documents rarely say whether the deduction is the vehicle's own tax on the shares it holds or the holder's tax on a dividend equivalent, nor why one deduction is the complete answer. A basis may well exist: dealer status of the entity that issues or hedges, a tax opinion, or a characterisation of the holder as owner. The point is only that the reader is not told which.

The third is the residual. Terms can exclude any gross-up, oblige holders to reimburse taxes imposed on the issuer, and allow redemption for tax reasons. If a tax were assessed later for past dividends, such clauses would place the cost on whoever holds at that time, while holders who sold in the meantime would have left at full value. The issuer's capitalisation sharpens this. The tax on a dividend equivalent is the holder's own liability; the issuer answers for it only as withholding agent (IRC § 1461). A bank issuer has a balance sheet to absorb an under-withholding. A special-purpose vehicle with nominal capital and limited-recourse terms has only the assets backing the tokens, so an assessment would be met from the collateral, which is to say by the holders at that time, unless a sponsor chose to step in. Whether a reimbursement claim against holders known only by a wallet address can be enforced is a practical question the documents do not address. A reinvesting token adds a mechanical one: with no cash payment to deduct from, any tax on the holder's entitlement has to come out of the amount reinvested or be met by the issuer, and the document should say which.

None of this indicates that anything is wrong. It indicates that an investor cannot establish from the document alone which of the four arithmetic cases applies.

VII

What to Look For, What to Ask

For any tokenised US share, an investor or adviser would want to know six things.

  1. The rate, the base and the level. What percentage is deducted, on what gross amount, and is it deducted from the vehicle's receipt or from the holder's entitlement?
  2. The tax owner. Who is treated as owning the underlying shares for US tax purposes: the holder, a trustee, or the issuer?
  3. The token's own status. Does the issuer treat the token as a separate instrument within the dividend-equivalent rules, and if a single deduction is applied, on what ground? Which legal entity acts as withholding agent, and in what status?
  4. Treaty relief. Can a holder entitled to a lower rate obtain it, at source or by reclaim, and what documentation is required?
  5. Reassessment. Who bears a later tax claim, and from which holders, current or former, could it be recovered? What capital stands behind the issuer if it does?
  6. The record. Does the holder receive, for each dividend, a statement of gross amount, each deduction, fees and net amount?

The same six items would serve as a disclosure template. A product that answers them in its offering document has told the investor which share of the dividend to expect and why.

—

The Rate Follows the Register

The cost described here is small today because the shares most often tokenised pay little or no dividend. It scales with yield. On a broad index yielding a little over one per cent, the gap between the statutory rate and a 15 per cent treaty rate is under twenty basis points a year. On a high-dividend portfolio it is several times that.

For professional investors the gap may weigh more than for retail. A pension fund can be entitled to exemption from US tax on dividends under its country's treaty, as qualifying Swiss pension institutions are (US–Switzerland treaty, Art. 10(3), and the related competent authority arrangements), and a flat-rate form asks such a holder to give up the full 30 per cent. An index mandate measured in basis points has little room for a structural shortfall. The objection has limits: standard net-return indices are calculated at the maximum rate, the one faced by a non-resident investor without treaty benefits (FTSE Russell, Withholding Tax Guide), so against those a flat-rate token does not lag. But an investor who can obtain the treaty rate through a conventional account has a reason to stay there.

Forms that keep a documented holder can deliver treaty rates. Forms that let the token pass to holders the paying chain has not documented cannot. The difference is one of tax documentation, not of anonymity: holders of freely transferable tokens are typically identified when they subscribe, redeem or trade through an intermediary, but that identification does not travel with the token to the party paying the dividend. If institutional demand for tokenised shares materialises, it is likely to favour the documented forms, or documented variants of the certificate, over the freely transferable ones. Two markets may result, one open and taxed at the flat rate, the other permissioned or custodial and taxed according to the holder. That would be a commercial division, not a technical one.

The obstacle described here is relief at source across borders. Where a source country taxes at a flat final rate, refunds through the holder's own tax return, or does not withhold at all, the paying chain has nothing to establish at the moment of payment, and a token's servicing is correspondingly lighter. Interest on US debt is close to that position. Dividends on US shares are not.

Three questions stay open. How each form is characterised for US tax purposes: as ownership, a trust interest, debt or an equity-linked instrument. Whether the vehicles behind the tokens stand inside or outside the dealer regime. And what the regulations expected to replace a decade of transitional guidance will say about either. Until those are answered, the practical conclusion is the one this library has reached before from other directions: the benefit follows the holder the system can identify. Identification alone is not enough; the entitlement, the certificate and the allocation record have to keep pace with every transfer. Whoever keeps the register is best placed to keep those too.


Sources

Written in a personal capacity. Analytical views only — not legal, tax or investment advice.

Julian Gretzinger — Investor and writer on monetary history, real wealth mechanics, and financial markets. substack.com/@juliangretzinger